Written by Rachel Torres, freelance business strategist who has converted 40+ one-time clients into retainers averaging $3,500/month. This is the exact procedure she runs with every qualified client.
Equipment Needed
Procedure Steps
Qualify Your Client List
Pull records of every client you've worked with in the past 12 months. Flag anyone who spent $3,000+ total or hired you 3+ times. These are retainer-ready.
Analyze Project History for Recurring Needs
Review the last 6 months of work for each qualified client. List every project type and how often it repeats. Look for natural monthly patterns: content, maintenance, reporting, updates, campaigns.
Design Your Retainer Packages
Create three tiers. Each includes specific deliverables with clear scope. Base pricing on their average monthly spend — retainer should be 15-20% less than ad-hoc total.
Tier 1 — Foundation: Core recurring deliverables, email support, 48-hr response time. Priced at 60% of their average monthly spend.
Tier 2 — Growth: Foundation + strategic input, priority scheduling, monthly check-in call. Priced at 80% of average spend.
Tier 3 — Premium: Full-service, dedicated hours, weekly calls, same-day response. Priced at 100-110% of average spend with added strategic value.
Build the Business Case
Create a one-page document showing: their total spend with you over 6 months, the retainer equivalent with savings highlighted, what's included in each tier, and the ROI of predictable budgeting.
Use this formula: Retainer Price = (Avg Monthly Spend × 0.85) + Priority Access Value. Example: $5,000 avg spend → $4,250 retainer + priority scheduling = $4,500/month package.
Time the Pitch
Send the pitch within 48 hours of delivering a strong result. The client is happiest right after you've proven value. Never pitch during a project crisis or right after a mistake.
Subject line: "A simpler way to handle [their recurring need] — proposal inside". Lead with their benefit: predictable costs, priority access, less admin overhead.
Handle Objections and Close
Expect three common objections. Have responses ready:
"It's too expensive" → Show their actual ad-hoc spend over 6 months vs. retainer cost. The retainer saves money.
"We don't need that much" → Offer Tier 1 with a 3-month trial. Lower commitment, proves value.
"We'll think about it" → Set a specific follow-up date (7 days). Send a summary email with the business case attached.
Onboard and Systematize
Once they sign: send a welcome email within 24 hours confirming package details, communication channels, billing schedule, and point of contact. Schedule a 30-minute kickoff call within week one.
Set up: recurring deliverable calendar, shared project board (Trello/Asana/Notion), automated invoicing on the 1st of each month, and a monthly report template showing work completed and results delivered.
Common Mistakes
- Pitching too early. Clients need 3+ months of work history before a retainer makes sense. Pitching after one project feels pushy and gets rejected.
- Underpricing to close. A retainer priced below cost creates resentment. You'll cut corners within 60 days and damage the relationship. Price for sustainable delivery.
- Vague deliverables. "Ongoing support" isn't a deliverable. "4 blog posts, 1 monthly report, and email support" is. Specificity prevents scope creep and disputes.
- No written contract. Verbal retainers collapse at the first disagreement. A 2-page contract protects both sides. Use it every time without exception.
- Skipping the onboarding process. A signed retainer without structured onboarding leads to chaos. Clients don't know how to submit work, deadlines slip, and churn happens within 90 days.
Get the Retainer Conversion Kit
Contract templates, pricing calculator, email scripts, and Rachel's full library of side income SOPs. Free.
Join 2,800+ men building side income · No spam · Unsubscribe anytime
Check Your Inbox
The Retainer Conversion Kit is on its way. Check spam if you don't see it in 5 minutes.